

After an accident, your car insurance will usually cost more at renewal, even if the accident wasn’t your fault, because insurers see any claim as a sign of higher risk. A fault claim usually costs more than a non-fault one, because it can also cut your no claims bonus. There’s no official figure for how much prices rise. It depends on the claim, your record and the insurer, which is why comparing quotes after a claim matters so much.
Insurers price claims differently, so your renewal quote may not be the cheapest. Compare car insurance from 130+ UK insurers via Brumble.
There’s no official average. Insurers don’t publish how much they add for a claim, and the figures you’ll see quoted online are estimates. What we do know is what drives the increase:
Claims are expensive for insurers. In 2025, UK motor insurers paid out a record £11.9 billion across 2.5 million claims, and repairs made up nearly £7.5 billion (63%) of that, according to the Association of British Insurers (ABI). Modern cars are full of sensors and cameras, which makes even small repairs costly.
The no claims bonus is the part of the increase we can put numbers on. Insurers publish their discount scales, and the middle average across them was 20% for 3 years and 24% for 5 years in 2025. One fault claim usually takes 2 years off your bonus: Admiral, for example, says one claim in a policy year loses 2 years.
| Example: average premium of £562 with a 5 year no claims bonus | Premium | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Before the claim (5 years, 24% discount) | £562 | None |
| Bonus stepped back to 3 years (20% discount) | £592 | +£30 |
| Bonus lost completely (no discount) | £739 | +£177 |
Brumble analysis using the ABI’s average premium for Q3 2026 (£562) and insurers’ published middle average discounts. This only shows the effect of the discount. Insurers also add to the price because the claim is on your record, and they don’t publish how much. Discounts vary a lot between insurers: the highest published average was 57.5% for 9 or more years, so some drivers have much more to lose.
A fault claim is one where your insurer pays out and can’t get all its money back from someone else. A non-fault claim is one where your insurer recovers everything from the person responsible. “Fault” doesn’t always mean you caused the accident: if someone hits your parked car and drives off, there’s no one to recover costs from, so it’s usually recorded as a fault claim.
| What happened | Usually recorded as | Effect on no claims bonus |
|---|---|---|
| Another driver hits you and their insurer accepts full liability | Non-fault | Usually not affected |
| You cause an accident | Fault | Reduced or lost, unless protected |
| You hit an animal and claim for repairs | Fault | Reduced or lost, unless protected |
| Hit and run, or someone damages your parked car and leaves | Fault | Reduced or lost, unless protected |
| Both drivers partly to blame (50/50) | Usually fault | Usually reduced |
| Windscreen repair under comprehensive cover | Often treated separately | Often not affected, so check your policy |
Even when you weren’t to blame, the claim goes on your record, and insurers’ data shows drivers who’ve had any accident are more likely to claim again. Until your insurer has recovered its costs from the other side, the claim may also be treated as open, which can push up a renewal quote that falls in the meantime. Once the costs are recovered, ask your insurer to confirm the claim is closed as non-fault.
A “fault” claim doesn’t always mean you caused the accident. It means your insurer couldn’t get its money back from someone else. That’s why getting the other driver’s details, photos and any dash cam footage matters so much: it helps your insurer recover its costs and keeps the claim off your record as a fault claim.
Your no claims bonus is a discount for each year you go without a fault claim. After a fault claim, insurers usually step it back by a set number of years, often 2 for one claim, or reset it to zero after more than one. After a non-fault claim where your insurer recovers its costs, your bonus is usually not affected, though it may be held back while the claim is open.
No claims bonus protection lets you make a set number of claims, often one or two within a few years, without losing your discount. It protects the discount percentage, not the price: your premium can still rise because of the claim. See our no claims bonus protection guide for each insurer’s discounts.
If a named driver on your policy causes an accident, it’s your no claims bonus that’s affected, because the bonus belongs to the policyholder.
Report it to your insurer Tell your insurer as soon as you can, even if you don’t want to claim. Most policies require you to report any accident.
The insurer works out who was at fault It looks at the evidence, such as photos, witness details and dash cam footage, and talks to the other driver’s insurer.
Your car is repaired or written off You usually pay your excess. If the car is a write-off, you get its market value, minus the excess.
The insurer tries to recover its costs If the other driver was to blame, your insurer claims from their insurer. This can take weeks or months.
The claim is recorded It’s logged on the industry’s claims database and affects your renewal price.
The law also has a rule for the scene: if anyone is injured, or you don’t exchange details with the other driver, you must report the accident to the police within 24 hours. For what to do at the scene, see what to do after a road traffic accident. If your claim is turned down, see what to do if your car insurance claim is rejected.
Check whether your policy has an “uninsured driver promise”, which many comprehensive policies include to protect your excess and no claims bonus. If not, the Motor Insurers’ Bureau (MIB) can help with compensation. You can also check if a car is insured.
Injury claims are often the most expensive part of a claim, so a claim involving injury is likely to have a bigger effect on your renewal price.
Most insurers ask about claims and accidents in the last 5 years when you get a quote. Incidents are recorded on the Claims and Underwriting Exchange (CUE), run by the Motor Insurers’ Bureau, and kept for 6 years from when the claim is closed. That includes incidents you reported but didn’t claim for. Our car insurance glossary explains terms like this. The effect on your price usually fades as the claim gets older, as long as you don’t claim again.
Insurers can check CUE. If you leave out a claim they ask about, they could cancel your policy or refuse to pay out when you need them.
Not always. You must report every accident, but you don’t have to claim. If the repair costs little more than your excess, paying yourself may cost less than the higher premiums over the next few years.
| Claiming may make sense | Paying yourself may make sense | |
|---|---|---|
| Repair cost | Much more than your excess | Close to your excess |
| No claims bonus | It’s protected, or short | It’s long and not protected |
| Other people involved | Someone else is injured or their car is damaged | Only minor damage to your own car |
| Write-off | Yes | Not applicable |
If another driver or their property was involved, let your insurer handle it. Agreeing to pay someone privately can go wrong if their costs turn out to be higher than expected.
For more ideas, see how to lower your car insurance, or check what drivers are paying in car insurance costs in 2026.
Even with a claim on your record, comparing could find you a better price. See quotes from 130+ insurers via Brumble.
Compare Car InsuranceThere’s no official figure. It depends on who was at fault, the size of the claim, your history and the insurer. If a fault claim steps a 5 year no claims bonus back to 3 years, the lost discount alone adds about £30 to an average £562 premium, and losing the bonus completely adds about £177, before any extra for the claim itself (Brumble analysis).
It can. The claim goes on your record and insurers see any accident as a sign of higher risk. The rise is usually smaller than for a fault claim, and your no claims bonus is usually protected once your insurer recovers its costs.
It’s the idea that buying car insurance about 26 days before your renewal date gets you a lower price. Which? found buying 26 days ahead was £138 cheaper than buying on the day, using GoCompare sales data from 2025.
Every policy covers injury to other people if you cause an accident. For your own injuries, you claim against the other driver’s insurer if they were at fault, and many comprehensive policies include limited personal accident cover.
Tell your insurer as soon as you can. Most policies require you to report accidents promptly, and leaving it late could affect your claim. Separately, if anyone is injured or you didn’t exchange details, you must tell the police within 24 hours.
It can, slightly. The incident is recorded on the CUE database and insurers may take it into account. Not reporting it could invalidate your policy, so always tell your insurer.
If another driver claims you caused an accident, your insurer investigates and deals with their claim. If you’re found at fault, it’s recorded as a fault claim and can affect your no claims bonus and premium.
Not always. If the repair costs little more than your excess, paying yourself may cost less than the higher premiums. You still need to report the accident to your insurer.
Your insurer pays the car’s market value, minus your excess. The claim is recorded, and if it was a fault claim your no claims bonus is affected. Check whether your policy ends or can move to a replacement car.
Yes. You can switch at renewal, and comparing after a claim is one of the most effective ways to avoid overpaying. You must tell your new insurer about the claim.
Association of British Insurers: £11.9 billion paid out in 2025 to support motorists across 2.5 million claims (February 2026); Motor Insurance Premium Tracker, Q3 2026. Insurers’ published no claims discount tables, 2025 (Brumble analysis). Admiral: What happens when someone claims on your car insurance. Motor Insurers’ Bureau: Claims and Underwriting Exchange (CUE). Road Traffic Act 1988, section 170. Civil Liability Act 2018 and the Whiplash Injury Regulations 2021. Which?: The cheapest day to buy car insurance (GoCompare data, 2025).
We use cookies to improve your experience and analyse site usage. Read our cookie policy for details.