Brumble Guides.
New analysis by Brumble combining government road data with RAC compensation figures reveals a stark postcode lottery - with Scottish drivers facing roads six times worse than England's, yet councils still rejecting 3 in 4 pothole claims
New analysis reveals a stark "postcode lottery" for UK drivers - with Scottish motorists facing roads six times worse than England's, yet still having almost no chance of getting compensation when pothole damage strikes.
The Brumble Pothole Postcode Index combines official government road condition data with RAC Freedom of Information figures on compensation claims to reveal which parts of Britain leave drivers most exposed to the cost of broken roads.
Our analysis found:
We scored each nation on three factors: road condition (government data), pothole claims per mile of road (RAC), and compensation success rate (RAC). Each factor was scored 1-10 (10 = worst) and combined into an overall index score out of 30.
| Rank | Nation | Road Condition | Pothole Impact | Compensation | Index Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scotland | 9/10 | 8/10 | 7/10 | 24/30 |
| 2 | Wales | 6/10 | 5/10 | 8/10 | 19/30 |
| 3 | England | 4/10 | 6/10 | 6/10 | 16/30 |
A higher score indicates worse conditions for drivers. Scotland's score of 24/30 reflects a combination of the worst road conditions in Britain, high levels of pothole damage claims, and low chances of receiving compensation.
According to Transport Scotland's Road Condition Indicator (RCI), 29% of Scottish local 'A' roads may require maintenance. For the entire local authority network, that figure rises to 34%.
To put that in perspective: if you drive on a Scottish 'A' road, roughly one in three stretches you encounter may need repair work. In England, it's closer to one in twenty.
Glasgow stands out as the worst-performing Scottish council, recording 2,794 pothole compensation claims in 2024 - more than double the 1,203 miles of road in its network. That's 2.3 claims for every single mile of road.
Edinburgh recorded approximately one claim per mile of road, alongside Staffordshire, Derbyshire, and Bury in England.
| Metric | Scotland | England | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local 'A' roads needing maintenance | 29% | 5% | 6× worse |
| All local roads needing maintenance | 34% | 17% (unclassified) | 2× worse |
| Motorways needing monitoring | 20.4% | 4% | 5× worse |
Welsh Government data shows 10.5% of trunk road surfaces were found to be at or below investigatory level for skidding resistance in 2024-25 - up from 10.3% the previous year. While Welsh motorways and trunk roads structurally perform better than Scotland's, drivers still face significant challenges when seeking compensation.
Carmarthenshire rejected 99% of pothole claims in 2024 - the highest rejection rate in Wales and one of the worst in Britain.
On the positive side, Bridgend was the only council in the entire UK to pay out 100% of claims it received (52 claims in total), though this may reflect stricter initial claim requirements rather than better roads.
Wrexham paid the highest average per claim in Wales at £2,026 - significantly above the UK average of £390.
| Welsh Council | Claims Rejected | Avg Payout | Notable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carmarthenshire | 99% | £312 | Worst rejection rate in Wales |
| Wrexham | 68% | £2,026 | Highest payouts in Wales |
| Bridgend | 0% | £445 | Only UK council to pay all claims |
England's roads are in better overall condition than Scotland's, with the Department for Transport reporting 5% of local 'A' roads categorised as "red" (needing maintenance) in 2025 - up from 4% in 2024.
However, conditions vary dramatically by region. Derbyshire saw the sharpest rise in pothole claims anywhere in Britain, jumping from 224 in 2021 to 3,307 in 2024 - an increase of nearly 1,400%.
Derbyshire also paid out the highest total compensation of any English council, spending an estimated £605,235 on pothole claims in 2024.
| Council | Claims 2024 | Change since 2021 | Total paid out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Derbyshire | 3,307 | +1,376% | £605,235 |
| Oxfordshire | 1,941 | +892% | £142,000 |
| Surrey | 1,513 | +284% | £98,500 |
| Essex | 1,247 | +156% | £87,300 |
Several English councils rejected virtually all compensation claims in 2024:
| Council | Claims received | Claims rejected | Rejection rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gloucestershire | 539 | 534 | 99% |
| Worcestershire | 148 | 146 | 99% |
| Medway | 144 | 142 | 99% |
| Telford & Wrekin | 77 | 76 | 99% |
On the other end of the scale, Merton in London paid out the highest average compensation per claim at £2,267 - nearly six times the national average of £390.
Our analysis reveals that drivers are effectively subsidising Britain's crumbling road network - whether they claim compensation or not.
Even drivers who successfully claim compensation are left £200 out of pocket on average. For the 74% whose claims are rejected, the options are stark:
If you claim on your insurance for pothole damage, most insurers treat it as an "at-fault" claim because there's no third party to recover costs from. This means you could lose some or all of your no-claims bonus, potentially increasing your premiums for up to five years.
For damage under £1,000, it's often cheaper to pay out of pocket than to lose your no-claims discount.
Important: Councils can defend claims by demonstrating they inspect roads regularly and repair defects within a reasonable timeframe. Your chances of success increase if:
The Brumble Pothole Postcode Index combines data from official government sources and RAC Freedom of Information requests to create a composite measure of driver hardship across Great Britain.
Each factor is scored on a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the worst outcome for drivers:
The three scores are added together to produce the final Pothole Postcode Index score out of 30. A higher score indicates worse conditions for drivers.
| Index Score | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| 25-30 | Severe hardship - worst roads, high damage, minimal compensation |
| 18-24 | High hardship - significant problems across multiple factors |
| 10-17 | Moderate hardship - some issues but not extreme |
| 1-9 | Low hardship - relatively good roads and/or fair compensation |
This index provides a high-level comparison between nations. Within each nation, conditions vary significantly by council area. The RAC FOI data covers 177 of 207 councils surveyed, representing 246,510 miles of road. Road condition measurement methodologies differ slightly between nations, though all use comparable survey techniques.
Has your car insurance renewal increased after a pot hole claim? Compare quotes via Brumble and see if you could save.
Compare Quotes Now
PCP and HP are the two most popular types of car finance in the UK. This guide explains how each one works, compares monthly payments and total costs with a worked example, and helps you decide which suits your budget and driving habits.
As a courier, it's important you have the right level of cover, read our comprehensive guide to ensure you don't get caught short.
Student car insurance is notoriously expensive, with the average UK student paying around £2,722 per year. This guide explains why premiums are so high for those in full-time education and what you can do to bring costs down legally.
